HOME|News|Canada AM|W5|Weather|Video|Sports|Entertainment|Programs|TV Listing|Autos|Contests
CTV Toronto
Jeffrey Baldwin
Young Jeffrey died in this house.

Young Jeffrey died in this house.

Trial of Jeffrey's grandparents wraps up

Updated: Fri Dec. 16 2005 9:06:56 PM

CTV.ca News Staff

The trial of two grandparents accused of letting their five-year-old grandson starve to death was set to wrap-up on Friday.

Elva Bottineau, 54, and her 53-year-old common-law husband Norman Kidman are on trial for first-degree murder in relation to their grandson Jeffrey Baldwin's death on Nov. 30, 2002. Both have pleaded not guilty.

For almost three months the University Avenue courtroom has heard the story of Jeffrey's final weeks living with his grandparents.

The Crown maintains the young boy was neglected, locked in an unheated room with his sister. He was left, without food, for long periods of time until he died of starvation.

Testimony was heard during the trial about how the children were allegedly treated.

A boarder staying in the house said the stench emanating from the room was overpowering. James Mills recalled that the children were "surrounded by feces and urine," and "treated worse than a dog."

Mills admitted he did nothing to help as Jeffrey starved to death before his eyes.

However, Mills was not the only one to come under scrutiny during the trial.

The Catholic Children's Aid Society placed Jeffrey in his grandparents' care, despite Bottineau's conviction for the death of her infant daughter and Kidman's record as a convicted child abuser.

A Children's Aid assessment of Bottineau conducted in 1970 described her as an "incompetent parent who was a danger to herself and others."

The assessment was supported by testimony from a psychologist who evaluated Bottineau and diagnosed her with mental retardation.

The agency had seized Jeffrey and his sister while it probed abuse allegations against their parents in 1998.

The society has since admitted mistakes were made in the case, and has changed its screening policy for family adoptions.

Jeffrey's ordeal deeply affected his paternal grandmother, Susan Dimitriadis, who listened to some of the testimony.

"It's very overwhelming, I think every day about it -- why and how -- and it's very difficult," Dimitriadis told CTV News in October. "It's hard to think about it."

Final arguments will be heard in this case on Jan. 16, 2005.

If Bottineau and Kidman are found guilty they will face automatic life sentences with no chance for parole for 25 years.


If you have any questions or comments about this story click here. If you have information to add click here. To contribute your own photos or videos click here.


CTV NEWS VIDEO PLAYER
Viewer
CTV Toronto: John Lancaster reports from the court
Related Stories
User Tools

Advertisement

What's On
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
Toronto Sat, Nov 21, 09
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
The Musical Brain
9:00pm
The Big Picture
Customize
Toronto Fri, Nov 20, 09
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
America's Next Top Model
9:00pm
2009 American Music Awards
Customize
Toronto Thu, Nov 19, 09
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
Gossip Girl
10:00pm
Two and a Half Men
10:30pm
The Big Bang Theory
Customize
Toronto Wed, Nov 18, 09
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
Customize
Toronto Tue, Nov 17, 09
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
10:00pm
Ghost Whisperer
Customize