HOME|News|Canada AM|W5|Weather|Video|Sports|Entertainment|Programs|TV Listing|Autos|Contests
CTV Toronto
MMP ballot

Majority of Ontario voters reject electoral reform

Updated: Wed Oct. 10 2007 11:59:08 AM

toronto.ctv.ca

Preliminary results from Wednesday's referendum showed Ontario voters do not want to change the way they elect politicians by way of a proposed mixed member proportional system (MMP).

Projections showed voters rejected the proposal by a margin of almost 2-1, meaning the current First-Past-the-Post system will remain.

At least 60 per cent of voters had to support the MMP plan for the overhaul to take place, and at least 50 per cent of voters in 64 of the 107 ridings were also required to support the proposition for the change to go through.

Approving the MMP system would have given citizens two votes in future elections -- one for the political party of their choice and another for a local candidate. The reform would have been implemented before the 2011 election.

Advocates argued the MMP system would have brought a balance of power in the legislature that better reflects the popular vote.

"What we would get under this proposal is a legislature where the proportion of seats held by parties is more or less exactly reflective of the proportion of the vote for those parties among the public," Political science professor Karen Bird told CTV Newsnet before ballots were cast on Wednesday.

"So what this has going for it is that it is a more accurate way of translating how voters are expressing their opinion into seats."

Other analysts said an MMP system would have taken away the need for "strategic voting." The way the current system works, voters will sometimes vote not for the party or candidate they support -- but for the person that will ensure defeat for the party they don't want to win.

The overhaul would have:

  • Increased the number of seats in the legislature to 129 seats -- 90 of those seats filled by local representatives elected by the public and 39 seats filled by list members chosen by the political party to fulfill the need for proportional representation;
  • These list members would have been made public by the party before an election under the MMP system; and
  • The political party with the most elected local representatives and the most party votes would have been formed the government.

This First-Past-the-Post works like this:

  • Ontario is divided into 107 electoral districts. Each voter gets to pick one representative they think should win a seat in the legislature;
  • The person with the most votes wins and will represent the riding in government;
  • The political party with the most representatives with seats in the legislature forms the government.

Those who opposed MMP argued the system was a step back for democracy.

"There are more politicians, less districts, less contact with citizens," Joseph Angolano, media director of the group No MMP, told CTV.ca recently.

One of his main concerns was that the list members would have been chosen by the party, not the people.

The referendum was the province's first in more than 80 years. The Ontario government commissioned a group, the Citizens' Assembly on Electoral Reform, to study the electoral system for months and form the ballot question.

Elections Ontario spent $6.8 million on their public education campaign, including holding hundreds of community presentations, sending out nearly 5 million flyers and advertising in newspapers, radio stations and on websites.

But Elections Ontario was accused of bungling the public awareness campaign, as the agency recently learned that roughly 3 million voters didn't even know there was a referendum question on the ballot, the Canadian Press reported.


If you have any questions or comments about this story click here. If you have information to add click here. To contribute your own photos or videos click here.


CTV NEWS VIDEO PLAYER
Viewer
CTV News: Voters appear to have status quo

CTV.ca Special

pop:Election Central

Ontario election

What you need to know to vote. Leader profiles, key ridings, the referendum and more. >

pop:Election Results

Election Results

Tap into CTV's election results system. All 107 ridings, plus key battles and more. >

pop:Where They Stand

Ontario Votes 2007- Where they stand

Examining where Ontario's main political leaders stand on key issues in the 2007 provincial election. >

pop:McGuinty Scorecard

Dalton McGuinty Progress Report

Score the leader. Did Dalton McGuinty deliver on his promises from the last election? >

pop:The Referendum

Elections Ontario

Ontario voters have a chance to choose a new electoral system. Here's how you decide. >

Leader Profiles

pop:Dalton McGuinty

Dalton McGuinty

A 'regular' guy with a big goal: winning back-to-back majority governments for the Liberal Party. >

pop:John Tory

John Tory

After voters thumped the Conservatives in 2003, the new leader began rebuilding the party in his own image. >

pop:Howard Hampton

Howard Hampton

If the NDP doesn't win on election night, he says voters will be happy with a minority government. >

pop:Frank de Jong

Frank de Jong

With polls showing the Green Party has up to 10 per cent of the electorate, he is playing against long odds. >

Related Stories
User Tools

Advertisement

What's On
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
Toronto Sat, Nov 21, 09
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
The Musical Brain
9:00pm
The Big Picture
Customize
Toronto Fri, Nov 20, 09
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
America's Next Top Model
9:00pm
2009 American Music Awards
Customize
Toronto Thu, Nov 19, 09
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
Gossip Girl
10:00pm
Two and a Half Men
10:30pm
The Big Bang Theory
Customize
Toronto Wed, Nov 18, 09
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
Customize
Toronto Tue, Nov 17, 09
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
10:00pm
Ghost Whisperer
Customize