HOME|News|Canada AM|W5|Weather|Video|Sports|Entertainment|Programs|TV Listing|Autos|Contests
CTV Toronto
Liberal MP Jim Karygiannis speaks to CTV News in the House of Commons on Thursday, Dec. 4, 2008.

Liberal MP Jim Karygiannis speaks to CTV News in the House of Commons on Thursday, Dec. 4, 2008.

Prime Minister Stephen Harper announces that Gov.-Gen. Michaelle Jean approved his recommendation to prorogue Parliament at Rideau Hall in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 4 , 2008. (Tom Hanson / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Prime Minister Stephen Harper announces that Gov.-Gen. Michaelle Jean approved his recommendation to prorogue Parliament at Rideau Hall in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 4 , 2008. (Tom Hanson / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion walks back up to his office after Parliament was prorogued, in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 4, 2008. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Liberal Leader Stephane Dion walks back up to his office after Parliament was prorogued, in Ottawa, Thursday, Dec. 4, 2008. (Fred Chartrand / THE CANADIAN PRESS)

Coalition won't last: T.O. Liberal MP

Updated: Thu Dec. 04 2008 6:21:06 PM

ctvtoronto.ca

A Toronto MP doesn't think a Liberal-NDP coalition to bring down the government will last into the New Year, following the announcement that Parliament has been suspended until January.

"I cannot see it holding together," Liberal Jim Karygiannis, veteran MP for Scarborough-Agincourt, told CTV News on Thursday.

The coalition also has the support of the Bloc Quebecois, but with 143 seats in Parliament, the Tories would need the support of 12 opposition MPs to clinch a majority and derail the coalition's stated goal of bringing down the government.

Karygiannis added that Liberals and New Democrats have a long history of battling each other, meaning some factions could end up pitting MPs in the coalition against each other.

The coalition's prospects weren't helped by an embarrassing episode on Wednesday night, when the Liberals were late to deliver a taped address to the nation featuring Liberal Leader Stephane Dion.

When the tape was finally put on the air, the video quality was blurry and of poor quality.

"That was the YouTube approach ... it was a disaster," said Karygiannis, who called on Dion to quit sooner rather than later.

"Unfortunately, Mr. Dion didn't do so good in the last election. We bombed. And he didn't do so good last night. And we bombed again."

Meanwhile, during a tense Liberal caucus meeting Thursday afternoon, other cracks in the coalition started to show through, according to CTV's Roger Smith.

"There is a fierce debate going on right now in that caucus room," he told CTV Newsnet as the MPs met behind closed doors in Ottawa.

"It seems the knives are out for Stephane Dion, and it's not just Jim Karygiannis carrying them."

However, Liberal leadership hopeful and Etobicoke-Lakeshore MP Michael Ignatieff emerged to dismiss the prospect of the coalition breaking apart as nonsense.

He called Karygiannis' comments "extremely disappointing" and his characterization of it to be entirely wrong.

"This caucus is 76 men and women striving to be worthy of the hour," said Ignatieff, adding that the Liberal and NDP are working in the best interests of Canadians facing an economic downturn.

"Every single one of us is trying to rise to the expectations that Canadians have of us."

Thousands did show up for a pro-coalition rally in Ottawa on Thursday, waving signs that had phrases such as "I'm a part of the 62 per cent majority."

A similar rally is planned for Toronto at noon on Saturday.  It will take place in from of Toronto City Hall. Dion and NDP Leader Jack Layton will address the crowd.

"Rally for Canada," a pro-government group, will hold its Toronto rally at Queen's Park on Saturday. It is scheduled to start at noon.

Parliament suspended until January

Earlier on Thursday, Gov. Gen. Michaelle Jean has approved Prime Minister Stephen Harper's request to suspend Parliament, agreeing to put the government on hold until the end of January.

Harper addressed the media at just before noon after about two-and-a-half hours of meetings at Rideau Hall.

"Following my advice, the Governor General has agreed to prorogue Parliament," Harper told reporters from the front steps of the building.

He said the decision reflects the will of Canadians.

"Last Friday I asked Canadians to give us their opinion on the parliamentary situation. That feedback has been overwhelming and very clear. They want Canada's government to continue to work on the agenda they voted for -- our plan to strengthen the economy."

Harper also said that when Parliament resumes, the first item on the agenda will be the presentation of the federal budget and he will spend his time working almost exclusively between now and then on the fiscal blueprint.

He opened the door to co-operating with the opposition parties on the budget, saying Canadians expect all parties "to get on with it."

"It's the opportunity to work in the next six weeks on these measures, and I invite all the opposition parties, especially those that have a responsibility to the whole of Canada, to work with us, to inform us of their detailed position and we will be there to listen," Harper said in French.

Harper was seeking a suspension of Parliament in order to avoid a confidence motion scheduled for Monday that would have likely toppled his government.

They had hoped Jean would deny the prorogation request and let the confidence motion go ahead. If it did, and the government fell, Jean would have to decide whether to send Canadians to the polls for another election, or grant the coalition the chance to win the confidence of the House of Commons and possibly take over government.

With files from CTV's Graham Richardon, Rosemary Thompson and Roger Smith


Please Add Comments(2)

Bill from Whitby
If the Three Stooges make it till the end of next week that will be surprising.



Angus
The three clowns can't work by themselves, how do they expect to work together!




If you have any questions or comments about this story click here. If you have information to add click here. To contribute your own photos or videos click here.


CTV NEWS VIDEO PLAYER
Viewer
CTV News: Graham Richardson on the political showdown
CTV Toronto: Austin Delaney with voter reaction
CTV Toronto: Mike Duffy with more on the public opinion of the conflict
CTV Newsnet: Rosemary Thompson on the decision
CTV Newsnet: Terry Stratton, Conservative Senator on how Westerners are viewing the political debate
CTV Newsnet: Luc Lavoie, former spokesperson for Brian Mulroney
CTV News: Graham Richardson on Harper's request to suspend parliament
CTV Newsnet: Prime Minister Stephen Harper speaks after meeting with Governor General
CTV Newsnet: Prime Minister Stephen Harper takes questions about how he work with the opposition
CTV Newsnet: Prime Minister Stephen Harper takes questions about whether he is simply delaying the inevitable
CTV Newsnet: Liberal Leader Stephane Dion reacts to the suspension of Parliament
CTV Newsnet: Liberal Leader Stephane Dion takes questions after the suspension of Parliament
CTV Newsnet: NDP Leader Jack Layton shares his thoughts after Jean's decision
CTV Newsnet: Bloc Leader Gilles Duceppe reacts to the decision to prorogue Parliament
CTV Newsnet: Liberal MP Ruby Dhalla discusses the need for monumental change
CTV Newsnet: Environment Minister Jim Prentice explains why he sees this as an opportunity
CTV Newsnet: Antonia Maioni, director of the McGill Institute for the Study of Canada, says Harper's 'date' with Quebec is over
CTV Newsnet: Jim Travers, national affairs columnist at the Toronto Star and Margaret Wente, columnist with The Globe and Mail, discuss what happens next
CTV Newsnet: Correspondents discuss the Governor General's decision and what is next for Canada

CTV.ca Special

pop:Bloc Talk

Bloc Talk

Harper's rhetoric on the Bloc risks alienating Quebec, experts say. >

pop:Coalition FAQ

The Centennial Flame burns on Parliament Hill in Ottawa as the Centre Block is seen in the background on Sunday Nov. 30, 2008.  (THE CANADIAN PRESS / Sean Kilpatrick)

Changing governments without an election. Can they do this? >

pop:Interactive

House of Commons

Who's who in the House of Commons: Find out where your MP sits. >

CTV Video Player

video:Harper's address

Harper address

Watch Stephen Harper's address to the Canadian people and reaction from analysts and pollsters. >

video:Dion's address

Dion address

Watch as Liberal Leader Stephane Dion responds with his economic plan. >

Related Stories
Web Links
User Tools

Advertisement

What's On
Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
Toronto Sat, Nov 21, 09
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order
9:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Law & Order
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
W5
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
Law & Order
10:00pm
Law & Order: Special Victims Unit
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
The Musical Brain
9:00pm
The Big Picture
Customize
Toronto Fri, Nov 20, 09
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
The Amazing Race
8:00pm
Cold Case
9:00pm
The Mentalist
10:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
10:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
The Amazing Race
10:00pm
Cold Case
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
7:30pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:00pm
The Amazing Race
9:00pm
Cold Case
10:00pm
The Mentalist
7:00pm
Road To Avonlea
8:00pm
America's Next Top Model
9:00pm
2009 American Music Awards
Customize
Toronto Thu, Nov 19, 09
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
7:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:30pm
The Middle
9:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
CSI: Miami
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
10:30pm
The Middle
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
9:30pm
The Middle
10:00pm
CSI: Miami
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
Gossip Girl
10:00pm
Two and a Half Men
10:30pm
The Big Bang Theory
Customize
Toronto Wed, Nov 18, 09
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
7:00pm
V
8:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
The Mentalist
9:00pm
V
10:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
V
9:00pm
Dancing with the Stars
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
Customize
Toronto Tue, Nov 17, 09
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
7:00pm
Medium
8:00pm
Criminal Minds
9:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
CSI: NY
9:00pm
Medium
10:00pm
Criminal Minds
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Medium
9:00pm
Criminal Minds
10:00pm
CSI: NY
8:00pm
Degrassi: The Next Generation
8:30pm
TMZ
9:00pm
So You Think You Can Dance
10:00pm
Ghost Whisperer
Customize