Current Conditions
Light snow
-13°C
Detailed Forecast

Trial begins in 2007 high school rugby death

Viewer

CTV News Video

CTV News: Scott Laurie on justice and sport
The disturbing death of a young rugby player in Ontario is raising questions once again about violence and aggression in school sports. The teen died after a scuffle during a game and today his teenage opponent went on trial for manslaughter.
CTV Toronto: John Musselman covers the trial
A teen is on trial for manslaughter, stemming from the 2007 death of a Mississauga teen on the rugby pitch. John Musselman reports.

A A   |   Print   |  

Facebook   

ctvtoronto.ca

Date: Monday May. 4, 2009 10:57 PM ET

A Mississauga teen saw his manslaughter trial begin in a Brampton courtroom today, one that has its genesis in a high school rugby game two years ago.

Witness Craig Inward testified Monday that the accused hit Castillo with a "spear tackle," driving him into the ground.

The victim, 15-year-old Manny Castillo of the Lorne Park Spartans, suffered a severe head injury. He died several days later after being taken off life support.

Inward said the accused -- who cannot be named due to provisions in the Youth Criminal Justice Act -- went out of control after being called for an infraction against Castillo in the May 7, 2007 match, "stamping his feet and swearing at the referee."

It soon became clear Castillo was seriously injured, he said.

Inward said the ball was at least 20 metres away when the incident happened, with no apparent reason behind the rough play.

A rugby coach himself, Inward said players can only tackle or contact opponents who are either in pursuit of the ball or have it in possession.

The 18-year-old accused, then a student at Erindale Secondary School, had originally been charged with aggravated assault. Police upgraded that to manslaughter, which means they believe the accused unlawfully caused the victim's death but didn't intend it to happen.

"Had he walked up to Manny Castillo on the street and slammed him into the ground and he died, (the accused) would be guilty of manslaughter," Crown attorney John Raftery said in his opening remarks.

"There is nothing magical because it happened on a rugby pitch."

Coroners conducted a post-mortem exam on Castillo, but there's no record of a cause of death being made public.

"It's probably one of those things that's evidentiary in nature, so it'll have to wait for the trial to come out," Const. Wayne Patterson, a Peel police spokesperson, told ctvtoronto.ca on Monday.

After Castillo's death, Manuel Castillo, the boy's father, described what happened as an accident.

"(If) somebody took a gun and shot my son, it's a different story, tried to assault (him), it's a different story, but an accident in a game? I don't think that boy is trying to kill somebody," he told CTV Toronto in a May 13, 2007 interview.

Manny's organs were donated through the Trillium Gift of Life Network.

The accused has been playing hockey in the Ontario Hockey League.

With a report from CTV Toronto's John Musselman and files from The Canadian Press


Share with your social Network:

Facebook DIGG Newsvine Delicious Twitter StumbeUpon Reddit Yahoo! Buzz

 

Advertisement

What's On

Sat Sun Mon Tue Wed
Toronto Sat, Feb 11, 12
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
7:00pm W5
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
7:00pm The Voice
9:00pm Smash
10:00pm W5
7:00pm The Voice
9:00pm Smash
10:00pm W5
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
7:00pm W5
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
7:00pm W5
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
7:00pm W5
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Fri, Feb 10, 12
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Pan Am
9:00pm Once Upon a Time
10:00pm Desperate Housewives
7:00pm Once Upon a Time
8:00pm Desperate Housewives
9:00pm Pan Am
10:00pm Whitney
10:30pm Hot in Cleveland
7:00pm Once Upon a Time
8:00pm Desperate Housewives
9:00pm Pan Am
10:00pm Whitney
10:30pm Hot in Cleveland
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Pan Am
9:00pm Once Upon a Time
10:00pm Desperate Housewives
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Pan Am
9:00pm Once Upon a Time
10:00pm Desperate Housewives
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm Once Upon a Time
9:00pm Desperate Housewives
10:00pm Pan Am
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Thu, Feb 9, 12
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
7:00pm The Voice
9:00pm Smash
7:00pm The Voice
9:00pm Smash
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
8:00pm Smash
9:00pm The Voice
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
8:00pm The Voice
10:00pm Smash
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Wed, Feb 8, 12
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Unforgettable
9:00pm Whitney
9:30pm Hot in Cleveland
10:00pm The River
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm The River
9:00pm Unforgettable
7:00pm Whitney
7:30pm Hot in Cleveland
8:00pm The River
9:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Unforgettable
9:00pm Whitney
9:30pm Hot in Cleveland
10:00pm The River
8:00pm Unforgettable
9:00pm Whitney
9:30pm Hot in Cleveland
10:00pm The River
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
8:00pm Whitney
8:30pm Hot in Cleveland
9:00pm The River
10:00pm Unforgettable
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize
Toronto Tue, Feb 7, 12
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
8:00pm CSI
9:00pm American Idol
7:00pm American Idol
9:00pm CSI
7:00pm American Idol
9:00pm CSI
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
8:00pm CSI
9:00pm American Idol
8:00pm CSI
9:00pm American Idol
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
8:00pm American Idol
10:00pm CSI
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
7:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
8:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
6:00am Live 8
A historic day of rock 'n' roll as CTV broadcasts concerts from around the world.
Customize

View full schedule